online reputation management
Managing Risk Insurance Coverage

Why Managing Your Reputation Online Is Critical for Your Business

Kathy Simpson
Kathy Simpson,Freelance Writer and Editor
Kathy Simpson
Freelance writer and editor with years of experience crafting content.
LinkedIn Profile
08/28/2025 5 min read
Your business reputation can help differentiate you from the competition. Learn more about managing your online reputation today.
Facebook LinkedIn Twitter Email Cancel
Learn More About Business Insurance
Explore business insurance options tailored to your needs.
Learn More
Learn More
Your business’s good reputation is one of its greatest assets. It differentiates you from the competition, and customers will pay a premium to do business with a reliable company they can trust.
 
In the past, a business’s reputation was established over time by word of mouth. Today, thanks to the Internet, reputations can quickly rise and fall based on online commentary instantly accessible to a wide audience. A great review can bring a welcome flood of business. A bad appraisal can do your business harm.
 
Defamatory statements, whether written or posted online, may be considered libel in a court of law. Most general liability policies offer protection for libelous damage your business may cause to another business or individual. Conversely, you can sue an offending party if you believe your business is the victim of false or damaging statements. However, such lawsuits can be costly and difficult to prove, and in the digital era when unexpected comments can pop up in surprising places, you need to pick your battles.

Proactive Online Reputation Management for Your Small Business

Companies of all sizes can benefit from online reputation management because people are probably talking about you online. They may be sharing a customer experience on Facebook, rating your business on Google, leaving a comment on your blog or writing a letter to the editor of your local newspaper. Potential customers who read these perspectives take them to heart.
 
Some 95% of consumers research products and businesses online before they make purchasing decisions and 84% say they trust online reviews as much as a personal recommendation. So it’s important to know what your customers are saying and take steps to respond in a way that will reflect favorably on you and your business.
 
These tips can help you take proactive steps in online reputation management for your small business—and may prevent you from having to go to court.

Online Reputation Management Tips

Do a Detailed Search

Online reputation management should begin with a thorough online search. Search for your name and your business’s name and repeat with all available search engines, including Google, Yahoo and Bing. Take note of what comes up, particularly on the first four to five pages of your search. If you encounter any undesirable content, including photos, remove what is under your control.

Check Social Media, Blogs and Business Directories

online reputation management services
Social media sites such as Facebook, LinkedIn and Twitter are popular places for customers to post comments and share feedback. Free online business directories such as Google My Business, Yellow Pages, Yelp and Angie’s List also encourage customer reviews and commentary. Visit these sites periodically to run a search for your business. To simplify the online reputation management process, try Yext, a free online service that lists all directories where your business appears. From here you can easily review and update your business information, such as your hours of operation and location. You can also scan all complaint websites in a single search using Go Fish Digital.

Respond to Negative Reviews

Online reputation management also focuses on watching for negative feedback and a key component of managing your reputation online is how you respond to any negativity. If you encounter negative comments about your business, take action quickly:
 
  • Contact websites where the negative commentary appears. They will remove content that violates their policies, but in the interest of sharing both positive and negative opinions, sites generally leave all reviews up unless you present a court subpoena as proof of libel.
  • Respond privately to complainants whose names you know. Thank them for their feedback, apologize for their unsatisfactory experience and gather more information to help you resolve their concerns in a way that is appropriate for the circumstances. For example, you may reimburse a customer for poor service or offer compensation such as a gift certificate to a local restaurant.
  • Respond online. Acknowledge the customer’s frustration and thank them for bringing the concern to your attention. Own up to any mistakes and outline what you will do or have done to repair the situation, especially if you’ve already had an offline conversation. Readers will see that you value hearing from your customers and care about their experience.
  • Be friendly and constructive in all of your communications. A rude, dismissive or defensive response can only further damage your reputation, while an even-tempered and thoughtful reply will show your concern and willingness to make things better.
To offset the effects of any negative reviews, encourage your satisfied customers to post positive reviews of your business. Seven out of 10 consumers will leave a review for a business when asked.

Sign Up for Google Alerts

Online reputation management services
Google Alerts are a simple way to stay on top of online reputation management for your business, including web pages, newspaper articles and blogs. Google Alerts are free and easy to set up, and you’ll receive an email whenever Google finds results that meet your search terms. You can also monitor references to your business on social media with tools such as Awario, Mention and Brand24 which are available for a monthly fee. Some mentions of your business may still slip through the cracks, but these tools equip you with a means to take prompt and proactive measures to manage your online reputation.
 
A few negative reviews don’t need to ruin your business. You can learn from them and improve your standing with customers based on your response. Your best defense is to be good to your customers and interact with goodwill, whether they’re right or wrong.

Online Reputation Management Services

There are many tools and online reputation management services that are designed to help you see and respond to reviews at scale, across multiple platforms. They make the process of finding online reviews and comments about your business simple—while giving you an efficient, one-stop place to manage your online reputation.
 

Our Favorite Online Reputation Management Services

Below are three online reputation management services worth checking out. Keep in mind that pricing generally depends on how many locations or users a business has, as well as the number of features, tools and capabilities the software offers. Prices can range anywhere from $50 to a few hundred dollars per month for a small company with one location.
 

ReviewTrackers

ReviewTrackers aggregates reviews of a business across more than 100 third-party sites, including the most popular customer review sites like Google, and Facebook. You can respond to both positive and negative reviews directly through the platform, and a mobile app gives you access from anywhere. Analytics allow you to track changes to your online reputation over time, such as whether your customer ratings are improving or worsening.
 

BirdEye

Not only does BirdEye allow you to monitor and respond to reviews from more than 150 sites, but you can also solicit reviews from your customers—along with a host of other features and options. For example, you can easily share customer reviews on your social media pages and benchmark your review performance against your top competitors.
 

Rize Reviews

Beyond letting you monitor customer feedback across many review sites, Rize Reviews gives you an easy way to email and text customers and ask for reviews. It also offers a widget for featuring your best customer reviews on your website and offers tools to make your reviews search-friendly on Google. If you have issues or questions, there’s a dedicated support team ready to help.
 
Being proactive about your company’s online reputation management means you will spot customer problems sooner and can address negative customer feedback about your business right away, before it compromises your image.

Help Your Business Grow and Succeed

Subscribe to our newsletter and receive articles and tools to help with all your small business needs.
 
Subscribe
Business Owner's Playbook

Learn More

Explore our resources for entrepreneurs ready to launch their business, providing expert guidance on business formation, strategy, finance, risk management and more. 
 

Related Articles

Brought to you by The Hartford. The content displayed is for information only and does not constitute an endorsement by, or represent the view of, The Hartford.
 
The Small Business Insights Center is a small business information blog site from The Hartford. We may receive compensation from companies we endorse on our blog. Any company we affiliate with has been fully reviewed and selected for their quality of service or product. If you're interested in learning specifically which companies we receive compensation from, you can check out our Affiliates Page.
 
Information and links from this article are provided for your convenience only. Neither references to third parties, nor the provision of any link imply an endorsement or association between The Hartford and the third party or non-Hartford site, respectively. The Hartford is not responsible for and makes no representation or warranty regarding the contents, completeness, accuracy or security of any material within this article or on such sites. Your use of information and access to such non-Hartford sites is at your own risk. You should always consult a professional.